Lessons To Learn

Today is International Holocaust Remembrance Day. The day commemorates the genocide and tragedy of WWII which is not that far back in our past. It also serves as an opportunity for both the Jewish and Gentile populations to reflect on what lessons there are still to learn.

Recently, I have been greatly disturbed by revelations made in Israel and reported in publications like Haaretz concerning the medical treatment of Ethiopian women. A treatment they receive because of their skin color. It has been revealed that groups of Ethiopian women have been sterilized without their knowledge and under false pretense by medical officials in Israel. For me this is horrifying and goes against what this day is supposed to symbolize.

As if that isn’t enough the Health Minister in Israel yesterday acknowledged that Ethiopian women were injected with long-term birth control shots without being told or informed of the health ramifications. These women are mostly Jewish but because they are black, the government wants their birth rate controlled. I find it remarkable the Israeli government can’t see the tragic irony in these practices.

On the other side there is a willingness to forget what WWII did to us. Former Italian PM Berlusconi praised Mussolini and managed to doze off at a Remembrance event. There is a neo-Nazi party fighting for the streets of Greece. Even in the U.S.A. I can take you down to the local pub and introduce you to a couple of neo-Nazis.

Part of this is ignorance. It is always easier to blame a minority, especially one not that well understood, for current social ills. Part of this though is self-inflicted. I can only speak to as an American but it doesn’t help those who wish to support Israel when Netanyahu insults Obama and the country. It doesn’t help that the Jewish Lobby in D.C. is neck-deep in political corruption and when people attempt to clean it up they are labeled as anti-Semite for wanting to change it. It reinforces stereotypical images.

Sometimes it feels like we have made progress. Nobody is running a pogrom and groups who suffered in the Holocaust like homosexuals and Jehovah Witnesses, while still facing uphill struggles, aren’t being systematically hunted down. Yet, Israel seems to have less intimate contact with the West than it did just 20 years ago (one reason I feel for the constant miscalculation in its dealings with the West) and the West is willingly allowing itself to push the events of that era to the background where it is often forgotten or at the least not fully realized.

There are still a lot of lessons to learn on this International Holocaust Remembrance Day. There are a lot of changes to be made and still a lot of the history from those nightmare years to uncover. I hope we take a moment today to reflect on our own lives and re-acquaint ourselves with the phrase “never forget”.





Categories: books, Everyday Life, history, israel, Politics, religion, travel | Tags: , , , , , , , | 6 Comments

Post navigation

6 thoughts on “Lessons To Learn

  1. Vera

    I´m actually not quite sure if these information about what happened to the Ethiopian women are correct. The articles I read about it described that these were long-term contraceptives, not sterilization ! And that the women knew about it (but were pushed to do it – which still is horrible.) But this makes quite a different. A huge different, I think. One case is about not allowing a group of people to have kids, one is about not getting kids in a situation of a few months where you probably don´t have a job nor a home. As I said: still shocking, but I wouldn´t draw any comparison to the eutanasie program of Nazi Germany.
    In general I don´t like it so much to point with the finger on Israel when it´s about learning a lesson about ww2. Perhaps I´m sensitive, cause the Germans are pretty good in this also: explaining Jews what they should have learned from WW2.

    • Jett

      There was a report earlier … I want to say at end of December … about the sterilization and apparently it has been going on for awhile. If I think of it tomorrow I will try and dig up a link for you although if I recall Haaretz had the best article on it. I just gotta find the link again 🙂

      The point I was trying to make – maybe poorly – is not so much ‘lessons should have learned’ but rather that there seems to be this tone deafness if you wish that these actions won’t naturally lead to these comparisions. You would think there would be a tendency to err to the side of caution in Israel but I don’t think that is the case any more. I think there was a time when it was. And I don’t think it is a broad acceptance of these attitudes but rather very much a minority albeit often by people with power. Nobody would suggest that someone like Lieberman or the bosses in Shas speak for most Israelis yet they have power and their racist views are well documented. Yet, this speaks to my point. If they weren’t Israeli but were instead say French, how would the media in Israel report their actions?

      • Vera

        Hm but I think I still don´t get it. “You would think there would be a tendency to err to the side of caution in Israel but I don’t think that is the case any more.” Why should Israel be more cautious with these things than any other state?

    • Jett

      BTW – I like it when you comment because it always instigates a good discussion 🙂 Hope all is well on your corner of the planet.

  2. Jett

    Because Israel can, more than anyone else, least afford the wrong perception in these areas so I think there would be the extra precaution. That is what I was saying there.

    • Vera

      Well, in my eyes Germany and other country that were responsible for the horrors can more, than anyone else, least afford the wrong perception in these areas. Just my point of view.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

Blog at WordPress.com.

%d bloggers like this: